JBD wrote:
engrick wrote:
... a label on each feeder bucket....
Too many labels can be a sensory overload and often means people eventually stop reading them.
In my experience, when there are labels on every MCC bucket or Busway plug, I consider the electrical safety program, per MFPA70E, to be suspect.
Really? Have you read NEC, the 2014 edition. In order to comply with the new requirements especially with mains in double ended switchgear you will need:
1. Shock hazard label. Multiple labels if there are multiple voltages present especially if there are different compartments, or if a capacitive trip device is in use which is becoming even more common as newer switchgear switches over to using magnetic actuators.
2. Arc flash hazard label. In all likelihood there are at least 3 of these. One for the normal case with the tie open, one for single ended operation, and one for double ended operation with the tie closed.
3. Voltage label(s).
4. "More than one source" label indicating the tie/second main.
5. "More than one source" label for the DC power supply.
6. For medium voltage, yet another "more than one source" sign if it's a fused disconnect for the fuses themselves.
7. Ground disconnecting warning label.
8. Various interrupting rating and other equipment rating labels.
9. A shock hazard warning label on the back side or other compartments.
10. A "high voltage" warning label on the door to the switchgear room even if all the equipment is enclosed (stupid but that's the rule).
11. An inspection/date label. Not required by NEC but it's almost impossible to manage compliance with NFPA 70B/NETA MTS (arising out of Chapter 3 of NFPA 70E) without it.
12. Identification of the purpose of the equipment, labels for all the lights and controls, etc., as well as an overall enclosure label. This is actually an NFPA 79 and OSHA requirement but is so pervasive that it should be mentioned. Although this entails lots of labels I'll be nice and lump it only into one category.
That's all the basics. And by the way, the signs need to be ANSI Z535 compliant. This is complicated by two requirements of ANSI Z535:
1. The wording, signal word, etc., are in DIRECT CONFLICT with the specified wording in NEC. For instance "DANGER -- HIGH VOLTAGE -- KEEP OUT" comes up a lot. Here are the issues:
A. The signal word must be in Z535 compliance. In the case of the signal word DANGER it must be a situation where a fatality or serious injury is going to happen without taking other precautions. An entrance to an electrical room with enclosed gear is only supposed to have WARNING or NOTICE, not DANGER.
B. The sign must describe the specific injury and action taken to avoid it. "HIGH VOLTAGE" is not an injury. SHOCK or ELECTROCUTION is the injury.
C. ANSI Z535 specifically states that NO MORE than 3 warnings can be used per task. Granted all 12 of the warnings above do not apply to every single task but you get the picture that it has gotten completely out of control.